She Wants Her Rich Husband to Defer to Their Kids’ Nanny. He Feels Like He’s Being Replaced. Who’s Right?

Written By admin

A Reddit user and her high-flying husband hired a nanny to help with their three young kids. She’s told him to defer to the nanny when he’s home and helping out with the children, but he feels like he’s being replaced. Here’s the full story.

The Background

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

The Original Poster (OP) has a husband and 3 kids. The youngest is just 10 months old, while the other two are 3 and 6 years old. Needless to say, it’s a handful – especially because they both have jobs.

Her husband’s a high-flyer who’s away from home a lot and she works a regular 9 to 5. Given the challenges, they decided to hire some help…

They Hired a Nanny

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Their oldest child went to daycare at first. But when their second came along, they decided to bring on board a nanny to look after the kids while OP was at work.

When they had their youngest, doing the night-time routine solo (remember, dad’s traveling for work most of the time) became too overwhelming – a reality made worse by the postpartum depression she’d developed. As a result, they brought the nanny on to help with dinner, bath-time, and bedtime as well.

It’s Working Out Great

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

This new setup has been great for OP. She’s formed a good relationship with the nanny, who’s amazing with the kids. And together they’ve established a routine and rhythm that works well for everyone. Everyone, that is, apart from Dad…

Problems Occur When Her Husband’s Home

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Although her husband’s out or away more often than not, he’s definitely around sometimes. He helps with the childcare at weekends. However, because he works so much, he doesn’t want to be too firm with the children when he’s actually there.

It Impacts the Nanny

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Occasionally, OP’s husband will be around at the same time as their nanny. But while she tries to stick to the usual routine and get the kids off to bed, her husband’s more inclined to let them off the hook, allow them to rough house, and muck around.

This might be fun for the kids, but it disrupts their routine and makes them late for bedtime.

The Nanny’s In an Awkward Position

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

The nanny’s very aware that she’s an employee and the last thing she wants is to undermine anybody. Yet she’s expressed feeling awkward about the situation to OP. Ultimately, the husband being there makes it harder for her to do her job properly.

Her Husband Wants the Nanny There

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

An obvious solution would be for the nanny to take the evening off when the husband’s home. However, he doesn’t want that to happen because he thinks it’d be too tricky to handle the kids by himself.

OP Wants Him to Follow the Nanny’s Lead

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

This is where the problem really starts. OP told her husband that if he needs the nanny there, then he should defer to her in caring for the kids. After all, the nanny a) knows the children best and b) is the one who has to deal with the trouble when they start misbehaving. Understandably, perhaps, he isn’t happy…

He Sees Things Differently

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

From her husband’s perspective, that seems unfair. After all, he’s the dad and the nanny’s an employee – he pays her salary, yet she’s the one giving the orders?

OP Gave Him an Ultimatum

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

OP’s on nanny’s side. Feeling the situation as it stands is too unfair on her, she gave her husband an ultimatum: either he defers to the nanny at bedtime and bathtime, or he doesn’t help out at all.

Her Husband Feels Replaced

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

In response to her request/instruction, her husband responded by saying OP’s letting the nanny replace him. Now she’s unsure if she’s the bad guy.

A Privileged Position

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

OP began her story by acknowledging that what she’s describing is a privileged issue. However, she wanted to get other people’s perspective.

Was she in the wrong for asking her husband to take a backseat when helping out with the kids – especially when he pays the nanny’s salary? Or was it a fair request given the problems that arise when he’s there and the fact it impacts the kids’ behavior when he’s not around?

Reddit had a lot to say…

People (Mostly) Sided With OP

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

The majority of responses on Reddit were firmly behind OP. The top comment, which has almost 50k upvotes, reads:

“I’m so angry reading these responses. Your husband doesn’t want to parent. Your husband wants to be Funtime Uncle, who comes in roles everyone up, dishes out sweets, makes sure they don’t make their bedtimes and then dips out when the children start having unpleasant reactions to the disruption…Dads also have to ******* parent. It is completely reasonable if the only partner doing any parenting puts their foot down on an unacceptable behavior partner.”

It’s a Common Problem in Society

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

That previous commenter continued:

“Why does dad always get to be the Funtime guy and mum always has to be the downer doing the actual parenting? This is a huge problem in society…You know what is really good for children having a father who is an active partner in parenting. It’s also completely false that children won’t recognize as they grow that dad didn’t give enough of a **** about them to actually be present in their lives. When they look back as adults it’s going to be mum they respect. Mum who provided the safe healthy environment for them to grow in.”

A Possible Solution

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Another top comment agreed with the last and offered thoughts on what they believe should happen:

“Agreed. Dad’s gone all the time so when he’s home, he wants to be seen as the fun friend, not the parent. The nanny either stays as he requests and he follows her routine or the nanny leaves and he deals with the **** part of parenting (bath, bedtimes, etc.) while keeping the kids on their routine. Otherwise eventually they’ll lose the nanny and the only loser there is going to be mom having to deal with all the **** herself when dad’s gone.”

The Husband Should Accept His Inexperience

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Some comments honed in on the husband’s apparent inability to handle his three kids, suggesting that’s reason enough for OP to make her request.

One said, “If this guy is not capable of getting a 3 and 6 year old bathed and to bed on his own then he should understand that it’s best to follow the lead of the adult who does it daily, employee or not.”

What Do You Think?

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

While the vast majority of people on Reddit sided with the OP, there are some dissenting voices that were on the husband’s side. So what do you think? Should OP have asked him to follow the nanny’s lead? Or should she let him continue as he is because he’s the dad? Or is there another way to tackle the problem entirely?

Drop a comment with your thoughts.


His Brother-In-Law’s Kids Ruined His Art Supplies, so He’s Taking Him to Small Claims Court

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

A Reddit user described how his brother-in-law’s kids just ruined hundreds of dollars worth of art supplies. After refusing to pay for them, OP’s planning to take him to small claims court. Click below to read the full story.


14 Surprising Facts about King Charles III

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

How much do you know about the new King of the United Kingdom? Test your knowledge of him with these 14 surprising facts.


He Gave Up His First-Class Plane Seat to Teach His Wife a Lesson. It Backfired.

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

A Reddit user recently gave up his first-class plane seat for a woman with a crying baby. But he didn’t do it all for her benefit. Read about what happened here.


His Ex Didn’t Want Him Around for Their Baby. 13 Years Later, She’s Demanding Child Support. Should He Pay?

Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

A Reddit user has asked her husband to step aside while their nanny handles the kids each evening. Now he feels replaced – especially because he pays the nanny’s salary. Click below to read the full story.


The images in this article in no way represent anyone featured in the story.

Source: Reddit.

Leave a Comment